Bookmark and Share

Public Safety

Cape Wind would pose hazards to marine vessel navigation, air traffic control, fishing vessel and gear deployment, and search and rescue efforts. Located in an area with over 200 days of fog per year and quickly changing weather, Cape Wind would create significant navigational hazards for thousands of commercial and recreational vessels and pose an unacceptable hazard to aviation safety, threatening the safety of millions of travelers crossing the Sound each year.

Marine Navigation
The 130 turbines would jeopardize navigational safety by creating obstructions that ferries, cargo ships, and pleasure craft would have to negotiate, not only in clear weather, but in dense fog and highly variable weather conditions characteristic of the Sound. The spinning turbine blades would also interfere with marine radar and impact search and rescue efforts. The project would crowd main navigation channels for ferries, cargo ships, and fishing boats, posing a serious risk of collision. The local ferry lines, which transport more than three million passengers every year, have called the project "an accident waiting to happen." 

The navigation chart below shows the 25-square-mile footprint of the Cape Wind project, which is dangerously close to passenger ferry and shipping routes.

Cape Wind's proposed turbines present 130 obstacles to navigation. The proposed Cape Wind project would be directly adjacent to a major shipping lane and passenger ferry routes. For a ship or boat traveling at just over five knots, the turbines would be spaced about two minutes apart, and only one minute apart at a speed of 12 knots, jeopardizing a ship or boat crew's ability to take avoidance action in an emergency.
 
The Steamship Authority, which transports roughly three million passengers each year, is critical of placing an industrial power plant in the middle of Nantucket Sound. The Steamship Authority, which makes more than 14,000 trips to Nantucket and Martha's Vineyard each year, states that the wind power plant "has the potential for creating a significant hazard to safe navigation." They go on to explain that "the concluding factor is that the proposed complex offers a significant number of potential hazards that cannot be ignored. Maritime history is testimony to the fact that accidents at sea happen quickly, often without warning, and in locations where they were least expected to occur."

The British Chamber of Shipping "has confirmed that there may be an impact on air and marine radar within 1.5 nautical miles of turbines" and "advocates the adoption of a precautionary separation zone of at least two nautical miles from recognized shipping lanes." The McGowan Group, in its February, 2006 assessment report: Impact of UK Offshore Renewable Energy Guidelines concluded that under UK standards and guidelines, the [Cape Wind] project lacks a detailed navigation risk assessment. "The impacts of this project to marine transportation, the marine environment and public safety are significant in a region plagued with challenging weather and currents for its varied waterway traffic."

A previous 2004 McGowan Group report focusing on the project's navigational safety impacts concluded that the Cape Wind project is "incompatible with the needs of marine transportation" in Nantucket Sound and poses unacceptable and unnecessary risk to cruise ships and ferry vessels, oil transport, fishing, and recreational users due to its proximity to active shipping channels."

 

Aviation Concerns
Cape Wind would pose a significant risk to the 400,000 flights and millions of passengers that traverse Nantucket Sound every year due to radar interference and its location in the center of three airports. It would cause both marine and aviation radar interference and be dangerously close to shipping lanes and Air Traffic Control operations. All three local airports strongly oppose the project and have expressed safety concerns for the millions of passengers flying over the Sound each year.  

The chart below shows  flights paths over Nantucket Sound on July 15, 2007. On average, there are 400,000 flights annually between Cape Cod, Martha's Vineyard, and Nantucket. There are over 2,000 flights per day in the summer months alone.

 

Studies by the British Ministry of Defense show that wind turbines confuse radar systems, causing air traffic controllers to lose track of planes in flight. Here in the United States, the United States Department of Defense (DOD) recently confirmed that wind turbines located within "line of sight" can interfere with radar systems.

Search and Rescue
The Cape Wind project would compromise Coast Guard search and rescue efforts. The inability of the Coast Guard to perform helicopter rescues in bad weather in the project area is of great concern. According to William H. Rypka, retired Coast Guard Lieutenant Commander, "Had [the turbines] been in place there is no possible way that a safe search by helicopter could have been conducted, much less the person rescued."

Access Restrictions
Because of the safety hazards posed by the construction and operation of offshore wind turbines, virtually every offshore wind project in Europe has some sort of public access and/or fishing restriction. Belgium forbids entry to any vessel (but the project and governmental exceptions) inside the 500m safety zone around the wind farms. This includes” sailing yachts, commercial vessels, dinghy’s, rafts, fishing vessels, work platforms, motorized yachts, aircraft, and anything else you can imagine.”

The McGowan report found that after construction, exclusionary zones may be required throughout the wind plant or around the base of each tower for the 20-25 year life of the project. The entire 25-square-mile area could be closed to all fishing throughout the project's life due to the significant navigational risk to commercial and recreational boats and the high likelihood of a marine casualty. This would have serious effects for Cape fishermen who derive as much as 60% of their livelihood from fishing in Horseshoe Shoal.